| Team | Game | Time | Description | Score |
|---|
| Team 8 | KC@BOS | Bot 2 | Jacoby Ellsbury Single, Will Middlebrooks to 2nd, pitcher Ervin Santana | 1-0 |
| Team 9 | CLE@HOU | Top 1 | Mark Reynolds Strikeout, pitcher Erik Bedard | 1--1 |
| Team 8 | CHC@MIL | Bot 1 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher Scott Feldman | 0--1 |
| Team 9 | CLE@HOU | Top 3 | Mark Reynolds Walk, pitcher Erik Bedard | 0-0 |
| Team 8 | CHC@MIL | Bot 4 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher Scott Feldman | -1-0 |
| Team 9 | MIN@CWS | Bot 4 | Alex Rios Walk, pitcher Scott Diamond | -1-1 |
| Team 8 | MIN@CWS | Bot 5 | Alexei Ramirez Strikeout, pitcher Scott Diamond | -2-1 |
| Team 8 | CHC@MIL | Bot 5 | Ryan Braun 3-Run Home Run, Jean Segura scores, Yuniesky Betancourt scores, pitcher Scott Feldman | 7-1 |
| Team 9 | CLE@HOU | Top 7 | Mark Reynolds 1-Run Home Run, pitcher Hector Ambriz | 7-8 |
| Team 8 | CHC@MIL | Bot 8 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher Shawn Camp | 6-8 |
| Team 9 | MIN@CWS | Bot 9 | Alex Rios Strikeout, pitcher Glen Perkins | 6-7 |
| Team 9 | DET@LAA | Top 1 | Prince Fielder Single, Miguel Cabrera to 2nd, Torii Hunter to 3rd, pitcher C.J. Wilson | 6-8 |
| Team 9 | DET@LAA | Top 5 | Prince Fielder 2-Run Home Run, Torii Hunter scores, pitcher C.J. Wilson | 6-16 |
| Team 9 | DET@LAA | Top 8 | Prince Fielder Strikeout, pitcher Sean Burnett | 6-15 |
| Team 9 | DET@LAA | Top 9 | Prince Fielder Walk, Miguel Cabrera to 2nd, Austin Jackson to 3rd, pitcher Ernesto Frieri | 6-16 |
| Team 8 | KC@BOS | Bot 1 | Jacoby Ellsbury Walk, pitcher Jeremy Guthrie | 7-16 |
| Team 8 | KC@BOS | Bot 3 | Jacoby Ellsbury Double, pitcher Jeremy Guthrie | 9-16 |
| Team 8 | KC@BOS | Bot 3 | Dustin Pedroia 1-Run Single, Jacoby Ellsbury scores, pitcher Jeremy Guthrie | 11-16 |
| Team 8 | KC@BOS | Bot 9 | Jacoby Ellsbury Single, pitcher Kelvin Herrera | 12-16 |
| Team 8 | KC@BOS | Bot 9 | Jacoby Ellsbury Stolen Base | 14-16 |
| Team 9 | STL@PHI | Top 1 | Carlos Beltrán Single, pitcher Kyle Kendrick | 14-17 |
| Team 8 | STL@PHI | Bot 6 | Michael Young Walk, pitcher Jake Westbrook | 15-17 |
| Team 9 | STL@PHI | Top 7 | Carlos Beltrán Walk, pitcher Antonio Bastardo | 15-18 |
| Team 8 | STL@PHI | Bot 8 | Michael Young Single, pitcher Mitchell Boggs | 16-18 |
| Team 8 | STL@PHI | Bot 8 | Ben Revere 1-Run Single, Domonic Brown to 2nd, Michael Young scores, pitcher Mitchell Boggs | 18-18 |
| Team 9 | STL@PHI | Top 9 | Matt Carpenter Out Ben Revere, pitcher Jonathan Papelbon | 18-19 |
| Team 9 | STL@PHI | Top 9 | Carlos Beltrán Single, pitcher Jonathan Papelbon | 18-19 |
| Team 9 | STL@PHI | Top 9 | Yadier Molina Strikeout, pitcher Jonathan Papelbon | 18-21 |
| | | Bonuses & Miscellaneous | 18-21 |