| Team | Game | Time | Description | Score |
|---|
| Team 9 | STL@PIT | Top 1 | Carlos Beltrán Single, Shane Robinson to 3rd, pitcher Jonathan Sanchez | 0-1 |
| Team 9 | STL@PIT | Top 1 | Yadier Molina 1-Run Out Garrett Jones, Matt Holliday to 3rd, Carlos Beltrán scores, pitcher Jonathan Sanchez | 0-3 |
| Team 9 | ARI@NYY | Bot 1 | Kevin Youkilis Single, Robinson Canó to 2nd, pitcher Brandon McCarthy | 0-4 |
| Team 8 | BOS@CLE | Top 2 | Jacoby Ellsbury 1-Run Single, David Ross to 3rd, Jonny Gomes scores, pitcher Ubaldo Jiménez | 2-4 |
| Team 8 | BOS@CLE | Top 2 | Jacoby Ellsbury Stolen Base | 4-4 |
| Team 8 | BOS@CLE | Top 2 | Mike Napoli 3-Run Double, Dustin Pedroia scores, Shane Victorino scores, Jacoby Ellsbury scores, pitcher Cody Allen | 6-4 |
| Team 9 | BOS@CLE | Bot 2 | Mark Reynolds Strikeout, pitcher Felix Doubront | 6-3 |
| Team 9 | ARI@NYY | Bot 4 | Kevin Youkilis Strikeout, pitcher Brandon McCarthy | 6-2 |
| Team 9 | BOS@CLE | Bot 4 | Mark Reynolds Walk, pitcher Felix Doubront | 6-3 |
| Team 9 | ARI@NYY | Bot 7 | Kevin Youkilis Single, pitcher Brad Ziegler | 6-4 |
| Team 9 | ARI@NYY | Bot 7 | Eduardo Núñez 1-Run Out Gerardo Parra, Kevin Youkilis scores, pitcher Brad Ziegler | 6-6 |
| Team 8 | BOS@CLE | Top 8 | Jacoby Ellsbury Strikeout, pitcher Rich Hill | 5-6 |
| Team 8 | CWS@TOR | Top 2 | Alexei Ramirez Single, Conor Gillaspie to 2nd, Paul Konerko to 3rd, pitcher Josh Johnson | 6-6 |
| Team 9 | BOS@CLE | Bot 8 | Mark Reynolds Walk, pitcher Alex Wilson | 6-7 |
| Team 8 | ARI@NYY | Top 9 | AJ Pollock Strikeout, pitcher Mariano Rivera | 8-7 |
| Team 8 | ARI@NYY | Top 9 | Cliff Pennington Out Lyle Overbay, pitcher Mariano Rivera | 9-7 |
| Team 8 | ARI@NYY | Top 9 | Gerardo Parra Out Robinson Canó, Lyle Overbay, pitcher Mariano Rivera | 10-7 |
| Team 9 | CWS@TOR | Top 3 | Alex Rios Double, pitcher Josh Johnson | 10-9 |
| Team 9 | CWS@TOR | Top 6 | Alex Rios Strikeout, pitcher Josh Johnson | 10-8 |
| Team 8 | CWS@TOR | Top 7 | Alexei Ramirez Walk, pitcher Josh Johnson | 11-8 |
| Team 8 | CWS@TOR | Top 9 | Alexei Ramirez Walk, pitcher Steve Delabar | 12-8 |
| Team 8 | PHI@CIN | Top 2 | Michael Young Single, pitcher Homer Bailey | 13-8 |
| Team 8 | KC@ATL | Bot 4 | Dan Uggla Strikeout, pitcher Jeremy Guthrie | 12-8 |
| Team 8 | PHI@CIN | Top 8 | Michael Young Strikeout, pitcher Homer Bailey | 11-8 |
| Team 8 | KC@ATL | Bot 8 | Dan Uggla 1-Run Home Run, pitcher Kelvin Herrera | 18-8 |
| Team 8 | SF@MIL | Bot 1 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher Barry Zito | 17-8 |
| Team 8 | SF@MIL | Bot 3 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher Barry Zito | 16-8 |
| Team 8 | SF@MIL | Bot 6 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher Jose Mijares | 15-8 |
| Team 8 | SF@MIL | Bot 8 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher George Kontos | 14-8 |
| Team 9 | DET@SEA | Top 1 | Prince Fielder Strikeout, pitcher Aaron Harang | 14-7 |
| Team 9 | DET@SEA | Top 5 | Prince Fielder Strikeout, pitcher Aaron Harang | 14-6 |
| Team 9 | DET@SEA | Top 7 | Prince Fielder Strikeout, pitcher Bobby LaFromboise | 14-5 |
| Team 9 | DET@SEA | Top 9 | Prince Fielder Strikeout, pitcher Yoervis Medina | 14-4 |
| | | Bonuses & Miscellaneous | 19-4 |