| Team | Game | Time | Description | Score |
|---|
| Yankees | SD@CIN | Bot 4 | Drew Stubbs Strikeout, pitcher Wade LeBlanc | -1-0 |
| Yankees | CHC@ATL | Bot 1 | Michael Bourn Single, pitcher Matt Garza | 0--1 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 1 | Brian McCann Strikeout, pitcher Matt Garza | 0-1 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 1 | Freddie Freeman Strikeout, pitcher Matt Garza | 0-3 |
| All Stars | DET@BAL | Top 2 | Victor Martínez Single, Miguel Cabrera to 3rd, pitcher Jo-Jo Reyes | 0-4 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 2 | Jason Heyward Out Tyler Colvin, pitcher Matt Garza | 0-5 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 2 | Alex Gonzalez Single, pitcher Matt Garza | 0-4 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 2 | Jose Constanza Single, Alex Gonzalez to 2nd, pitcher Matt Garza | 0-3 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 2 | Brandon Beachy Strikeout, pitcher Matt Garza | 0-5 |
| Yankees | CHC@ATL | Bot 2 | Michael Bourn 1-Run Single, Jose Constanza to 3rd, Alex Gonzalez scores, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-4 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 2 | Martín Prado 1-Run Single, Michael Bourn to 2nd, Jose Constanza scores, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-3 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 2 | Brian McCann Out Geovany Soto, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-4 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 3 | Dan Uggla Out Carlos Pena, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-5 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 3 | Freddie Freeman Strikeout, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-7 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 3 | Jason Heyward Out Darwin Barney, Carlos Pena, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-8 |
| All Stars | DET@BAL | Top 4 | Victor Martínez Strikeout, pitcher Jo-Jo Reyes | 2-7 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 4 | Alex Gonzalez Out Tyler Colvin, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-8 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 4 | Jose Constanza Walk, pitcher Matt Garza | 2-7 |
| Yankees | CHC@ATL | Bot 4 | Michael Bourn 1-Run Single, Jose Constanza scores, pitcher Matt Garza | 4-6 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 4 | Martín Prado Out Marlon Byrd, pitcher Matt Garza | 4-7 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 5 | Brian McCann Out Carlos Pena, pitcher Matt Garza | 4-8 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 5 | Dan Uggla Out Darwin Barney, pitcher Matt Garza | 4-9 |
| All Stars | CHC@ATL | Bot 5 | Freddie Freeman Out Starlin Castro, pitcher Matt Garza | 4-10 |
| All Stars | DET@BAL | Top 9 | Victor Martínez Single, pitcher Kevin Gregg | 4-11 |
| Yankees | CHC@ATL | Bot 9 | Michael Bourn Walk, pitcher Carlos Marmol | 5-11 |
| Yankees | CHC@ATL | Bot 9 | Michael Bourn Stolen Base | 7-11 |
| Yankees | KC@CWS | Bot 1 | Paul Konerko Single, Alexei Ramirez to 3rd, pitcher Jeff Francis | 8-11 |
| Yankees | KC@CWS | Bot 1 | Brent Lillibridge 3-Run Home Run, Carlos Quentin scores, Paul Konerko scores, pitcher Jeff Francis | 10-11 |
| All Stars | PIT@MIL | Bot 1 | Ryan Braun Walk, pitcher Charlie Morton | 10-12 |
| Yankees | KC@CWS | Bot 2 | Paul Konerko Single, Alexei Ramirez to 2nd, pitcher Jeff Francis | 11-12 |
| All Stars | PIT@MIL | Bot 4 | Ryan Braun Strikeout, pitcher Charlie Morton | 11-11 |
| Yankees | KC@CWS | Bot 6 | Paul Konerko Walk, pitcher Nate Adcock | 12-11 |
| All Stars | PIT@MIL | Bot 6 | Ryan Braun Single, Nyjer Morgan to 2nd, pitcher Charlie Morton | 12-12 |
| Yankees | KC@CWS | Bot 8 | Paul Konerko Single, Alexei Ramirez to 3rd, pitcher Joakim Soria | 13-12 |
| All Stars | PIT@MIL | Bot 8 | Ryan Braun 1-Run Single, Nyjer Morgan to 3rd, Jerry Hairston scores, pitcher Joel Hanrahan | 13-14 |
| All Stars | TEX@OAK | Top 1 | Nelson Cruz Single, Michael Young to 2nd, Josh Hamilton to 3rd, pitcher Rich Harden | 13-15 |
| All Stars | TEX@OAK | Top 3 | Nelson Cruz Walk, pitcher Rich Harden | 13-16 |
| All Stars | TEX@OAK | Top 6 | Nelson Cruz Single, pitcher Bruce Billings | 13-17 |
| Yankees | TEX@OAK | Bot 9 | Hideki Matsui Strikeout, pitcher Neftali Feliz | 15-17 |
| Yankees | TEX@OAK | Bot 9 | Josh Willingham Out Mike Napoli, pitcher Neftali Feliz | 16-17 |
| All Stars | BOS@SEA | Top 8 | Dustin Pedroia Single, pitcher Jeff Gray | 16-18 |
| All Stars | BOS@SEA | Top 8 | Kevin Youkilis 2-Run Home Run, Dustin Pedroia scores, pitcher Jeff Gray | 16-20 |
| Yankees | COL@STL | Top 1 | Carlos González Double, pitcher Edwin Jackson | 18-20 |
| Yankees | COL@STL | Top 1 | Troy Tulowitzki 1-Run Single, Carlos González scores, pitcher Edwin Jackson | 20-20 |
| Yankees | COL@STL | Top 7 | Carlos González Walk, Mark Ellis to 2nd, Eric Young Jr. to 3rd, pitcher Arthur Rhodes | 21-20 |
| | | Bonuses & Miscellaneous | 26-16 |