In order to truly reflect the value of Punters, there needs to be points for yards downed inside the 20.
I think that what you've done with the Punter scoring is OK (currently we give 2 points for all punts downed inside the 20), but you have find a way to give more points for the deeper the ball is downed inside the 20. Whether it would be easier to give 1 point for a punt downed inside the 20 plus 0.1 for every yard getting closer to the endzone OR 3 points and -0.1 for every yard from the endzone, the end result would be the same. Punts downed inside the 20 would range from a bonus of 1.1 to 2.9 depending on what yardline (19-1) the ball is downed at.
I would settle for bonus points on punts downed inside 15, 10 or 5 yard line but I'm not sure that would be much easier to track. I won't stop asking for this feature. You added Punters. Now let's make better scoring (like you did with the sack yards).
MonteMWed 7/29/20 11:22 AM
In order to truly reflect the value of Punters, there needs to be points for yards downed inside the 20.
I think that what you've done with the Punter scoring is OK (currently we give 2 points for all punts downed inside the 20), but you have find a way to give more points for the deeper the ball is downed inside the 20. Whether it would be easier to give 1 point for a punt downed inside the 20 plus 0.1 for every yard getting closer to the endzone OR 3 points and -0.1 for every yard from the endzone, the end result would be the same. Punts downed inside the 20 would range from a bonus of 1.1 to 2.9 depending on what yardline (19-1) the ball is downed at.
I would settle for bonus points on punts downed inside 15, 10 or 5 yard line but I'm not sure that would be much easier to track. I won't stop asking for this feature. You added Punters. Now let's make better scoring (like you did with the sack yards).
MonteMWed 2/9/22 4:45 PM
In my continued lobbying to have slightly improved scoring for Punters, Michael Dickson's 2021 Season by week:
1. 4=8pts as opposed to (12, 15, 14, 10) 1.8+1.5+1.6+2= 6.9pts
2. 2=4pts as opposed to (8, 18) 2.2+1.2= 3.4pts
3. 1=2pts as opposed to (11) 1.9pts
4. 2=4pts as opposed to (18, 9) 1.2+2.1= 3.3pts
5. 4=8pts as opposed to (12, 4, 18, 11) 1.8+2.6+1.2+1.9= 7.5pts
6. 1=2pts as opposed to (16) 1.4pts
7. 3=6pts as opposed to (12, 15, 15) 1.8+1.5+1.5= 4.8pts
8. 3=6pts as opposed to (19, 12, 9) 1.1+1.8+2.1= 5pts
9. bye
10. 4=8pts as opposed to (7, 9, 17, 13) 2.3+2.1+1.3+1.7= 7.4pts
11. 3=6pts as opposed to (18, 5, 15) 1.2+2.5+1.5= 5.2pts
12. 3=6pts as opposed to (9, 9, 13) 2.1+2.1+1.7= 5.9pts
13. 2=4pts as opposed to (8, 8) 2.2+2.2= 4.4pts
14. 2=4pts as opposed to (2, 18) 2.8+1.2= 4pts
15. 3=6pts as opposed to (12, 12, 13) 1.8+1.8+1.7= 5.3pts
The total points I got for punts inside the 20 was 78 points, but with better scoring it would have been only 66.4
Maybe I should adjust my hypothetical scoring to 0.2 per yard inside the 20. It sure would be nice to have that option.
noitankcapflowThu 2/10/22 12:39 PM
dickson has 3895 points in my league