In order to truly reflect the value of Punters, there needs to be points for yards downed inside the 20.
I think that what you've done with the Punter scoring is OK (currently we give 2 points for all punts downed inside the 20), but you have find a way to give more points for the deeper the ball is downed inside the 20. Whether it would be easier to give 1 point for a punt downed inside the 20 plus 0.1 for every yard getting closer to the endzone OR 3 points and -0.1 for every yard from the endzone, the end result would be the same. Punts downed inside the 20 would range from a bonus of 1.1 to 2.9 depending on what yardline (19-1) the ball is downed at.
I would settle for bonus points on punts downed inside 15, 10 or 5 yard line but I'm not sure that would be much easier to track. I won't stop asking for this feature. You added Punters. Now let's make better scoring (like you did with the sack yards).
Watching Johnny Hekker punt last night was impressive. With the scoring we have, he got 10 points for having all 5 punts downed inside the 20. He should have received 12.1 points for punts down at the 7 (2.3), 10 (2), 1 (2.9), 6 (2.4), and 5 (2.5).
MonteMWed 7/29/20 11:22 AM
In order to truly reflect the value of Punters, there needs to be points for yards downed inside the 20.
I think that what you've done with the Punter scoring is OK (currently we give 2 points for all punts downed inside the 20), but you have find a way to give more points for the deeper the ball is downed inside the 20. Whether it would be easier to give 1 point for a punt downed inside the 20 plus 0.1 for every yard getting closer to the endzone OR 3 points and -0.1 for every yard from the endzone, the end result would be the same. Punts downed inside the 20 would range from a bonus of 1.1 to 2.9 depending on what yardline (19-1) the ball is downed at.
I would settle for bonus points on punts downed inside 15, 10 or 5 yard line but I'm not sure that would be much easier to track. I won't stop asking for this feature. You added Punters. Now let's make better scoring (like you did with the sack yards).
MonteMTue 10/27/20 3:07 PM
Watching Johnny Hekker punt last night was impressive. With the scoring we have, he got 10 points for having all 5 punts downed inside the 20. He should have received 12.1 points for punts down at the 7 (2.3), 10 (2), 1 (2.9), 6 (2.4), and 5 (2.5).