James Reimer allowed four goals on 27 shots, but earned a victory in the Maple Leafs 5-4 overtime win over the New York Islanders Thursday. Reimer looked shaky throughout this contest, often mishandling the puck and turning the puck over to the Isles. While this wasn't a performance to remember, the young netminder looked strong prior to suffering his most recent injury and appears to have the trust of coach Randy Carlyle.