| Team | | Time | Down | Distance | Pos | Description | Score | Max Pts |
|---|
| CLE | 1st | 11:45 | | | NYJ 15 | Cody Parkey XP | 0-7 | 1 |
| NYJ | 1st | 3:11 | | | NYJ 35 | Jalin Marshall 18 yard Kick Return Attempt Ed Reynolds | 0-10 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 12:44 | | | CLE 15 | Nick Folk XP | 7-10 | 1 |
| CLE | 2nd | 1:51 | | | NYJ 15 | Cody Parkey XP | 7-17 | 1 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 15:00 | | | NYJ 35 | Nick Marshall 24 yard Kick Return Attempt Ricardo Louis | 7-20 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 8:15 | | | CLE 15 | Nick Folk XP | 14-20 | 1 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 2:11 | | | CLE 15 | Nick Folk XP | 21-20 | 1 |
| CLE | 3rd | 2:11 | | | CLE 35 | Ricardo Louis 24 yard Kick Return Attempt Josh Martin | 21-20 | |
| NYJ | 4th | 9:38 | | | CLE 15 | Nick Folk XP | 28-20 | 1 |
| CLE | 4th | 4:04 | | | CLE 35 | George Atkinson 15 yard Kick Return Attempt Josh Martin | 31-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 0:12 | | | NYJ 2 | Terrelle Pryor 2 Pt Conversion Passing from Josh McCown | 31-28 | 2 |
| CLE | 2nd | 5:25 | 3rd | 1 | CLE 39 | Duke Johnson 16 yard Rushing Attempt Marcus Gilchrist | 7-10 | 1.6 |
| CLE | 2nd | 1:55 | 1st | Goal | NYJ 1 | Isaiah Crowell 1 yard Rushing TD | 7-16 | 6.1 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 10:55 | 3rd | 1 | CLE 40 | Bilal Powell 3 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Christian Kirksey | 7-20 | 0.3 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 2:15 | 4th | 1 | CLE 4 | Matt Forte 4 yard Rushing TD | 20-20 | 6.4 |
| NYJ | 4th | 14:56 | 3rd | 1 | NYJ 45 | Ryan Fitzpatrick 1 yard Rushing Attempt Christian Kirksey | 21-20 | 0.1 |
| CLE | 4th | 0:19 | 2nd | Goal | NYJ 1 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Gary Barnidge | 31-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 0:15 | 3rd | Goal | NYJ 1 | Andrew Hawkins 1 yard Passing TD from Josh McCown | 31-26 | 6.1 |
| CLE | 1st | 3:20 | 3rd | 2 | NYJ 23 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Andrew Hawkins | 0-7 | |
| CLE | 1st | 3:15 | 4th | 2 | NYJ 23 | Cody Parkey 41 yard Field Goal Made | 0-10 | 4 |
| CLE | 2nd | 9:53 | 3rd | 2 | CLE 36 | Terrelle Pryor 15 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darrelle Revis | 7-10 | 1.5 |
| NYJ | 4th | 10:28 | 1st | Goal | CLE 2 | Matt Forte Rushing Attempt Jamie Meder | 21-20 | |
| NYJ | 4th | 9:42 | 2nd | Goal | CLE 2 | Matt Forte 2 yard Rushing TD | 27-20 | 6.2 |
| CLE | 4th | 0:29 | 1st | Goal | NYJ 2 | Isaiah Crowell 1 yard Rushing Attempt David Harris | 31-20 | 0.1 |
| CLE | 4th | 2:00 | 3rd | 3 | Midfield | Duke Johnson 6 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Jarvis Jenkins | 31-20 | 0.6 |
| NYJ | 1st | 8:13 | 4th | 4 | NYJ 19 | Jalin Marshall 0 yard Punt Return Attempt Christian Kirksey | 0-7 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 6:42 | 3rd | 4 | NYJ 36 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Quincy Enunwa Carl Nassib | 7-10 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 9:44 | 2nd | 4 | CLE 31 | Brandon Marshall 6 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Christian Kirksey | 7-20 | 0.6 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 0:33 | 3rd | 4 | NYJ 25 | Brandon Marshall 11 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Joe Haden | 21-20 | 1.1 |
| NYJ | 4th | 13:14 | 2nd | 4 | CLE 48 | Robbie Chosen 6 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Jamar Taylor | 21-20 | 0.6 |
| CLE | 1st | 11:52 | 2nd | Goal | NYJ 5 | Andrew Hawkins 5 yard Passing TD from Josh McCown | 0-6 | 6.5 |
| NYJ | 1st | 10:21 | 3rd | 5 | NYJ 30 | Ryan Fitzpatrick 4 yard Rushing Attempt Briean Boddy-Calhoun | 0-7 | 0.4 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 14:17 | 2nd | 5 | NYJ 27 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Quincy Enunwa Jamar Taylor | 7-20 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 14:11 | 3rd | 5 | NYJ 27 | Bilal Powell 5 yard Rushing Attempt Xavier Cooper | 7-20 | 0.5 |
| CLE | 3rd | 6:51 | 3rd | 5 | CLE 30 | Ricardo Louis 25 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Marcus Gilchrist | 14-20 | 2.5 |
| NYJ | 4th | 11:14 | 2nd | 5 | CLE 17 | Matt Forte 15 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Joe Haden | 21-20 | 1.5 |
| NYJ | 4th | 9:09 | 2nd | 5 | NYJ 30 | Josh McCown Pass to Terrelle Pryor Interception by Marcus Gilchrist Terrelle Pryor | 28-20 | 2 |
| CLE | 4th | 5:27 | 1st | 5 | CLE 6 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Randall Telfer | 28-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 5:22 | 2nd | 5 | CLE 6 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Gary Barnidge Calvin Pryor | 28-20 | |
| NYJ | 4th | 5:19 | 3rd | 5 | NYJ 6 | Josh McCown Pass to Duke Johnson Interception by Lorenzo Mauldin Cameron Erving | 28-20 | 2 |
| NYJ | 4th | 4:18 | 3rd | Goal | CLE 5 | Quincy Enunwa -1 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Joe Schobert | 28-20 | -0.05 |
| NYJ | 1st | 11:05 | 2nd | 6 | NYJ 29 | Matt Forte 1 yard Rushing Attempt Jamie Meder | 0-7 | 0.1 |
| NYJ | 1st | 2:32 | 2nd | 6 | NYJ 17 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Robbie Chosen Jamar Taylor | 0-10 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 11:53 | 4th | 6 | NYJ 29 | Jalin Marshall 15 yard Punt Return Attempt George Atkinson | 7-10 | |
| NYJ | 4th | 4:08 | 4th | Goal | CLE 6 | Nick Folk 24 yard Field Goal Made | 31-20 | 3 |
| CLE | 1st | 3:53 | 2nd | 7 | NYJ 28 | Isaiah Crowell 5 yard Rushing Attempt Rontez Miles | 0-7 | 0.5 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 15:00 | 2nd | 7 | NYJ 32 | Quincy Enunwa 13 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Ibraheim Campbell | 0-10 | 1.3 |
| CLE | 2nd | 2:46 | 2nd | 7 | NYJ 14 | Andrew Hawkins 1 yard Passing Completion from Kevin Hogan Darryl Roberts | 7-10 | 0.1 |
| CLE | 3rd | 1:21 | 3rd | 7 | CLE 22 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Terrelle Pryor | 21-20 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 13:42 | 2nd | 8 | NYJ 47 | Matt Forte 18 yard Rushing Attempt Demario Davis | 0-10 | 1.8 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 7:26 | 2nd | 8 | NYJ 32 | Matt Forte 4 yard Rushing Attempt Tramon Williams | 7-10 | 0.4 |
| NYJ | 4th | 5:13 | 1st | Goal | CLE 8 | Matt Forte Rushing Attempt Christian Kirksey | 28-20 | |
| NYJ | 4th | 4:29 | 2nd | Goal | CLE 8 | Matt Forte 3 yard Rushing Attempt Danny Shelton | 28-20 | 0.3 |
| CLE | 1st | 12:31 | 1st | Goal | NYJ 9 | Isaiah Crowell 4 yard Rushing Attempt Leonard Williams | 0-0 | 0.4 |
| CLE | 2nd | 0:04 | 4th | Goal | NYJ 9 | Cody Parkey 27 yard Field Goal Made | 7-20 | 3 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 11:28 | 2nd | 9 | CLE 48 | Ryan Fitzpatrick 8 yard Rushing Attempt Tramon Williams | 7-20 | 0.8 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 8:24 | 2nd | 9 | CLE 24 | Quincy Enunwa 24 yard Passing TD from Ryan Fitzpatrick | 13-20 | 8.4 |
| CLE | 1st | 15:00 | 1st | 10 | CLE 25 | Gary Barnidge 32 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Julian Stanford | 0-0 | 3.2 |
| CLE | 1st | 14:30 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 43 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Randall Telfer | 0-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 14:26 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 43 | Isaiah Crowell Rushing Attempt Julian Stanford | 0-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 13:46 | 3rd | 10 | NYJ 43 | Terrelle Pryor 24 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Marcus Gilchrist | 0-0 | 2.4 |
| CLE | 1st | 13:12 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 19 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Ricardo Louis | 0-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 13:08 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 19 | Rashard Higgins 10 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darryl Roberts | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYJ | 1st | 11:45 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 25 | Matt Forte 4 yard Rushing Attempt Emmanuel Ogbah | 0-7 | 0.4 |
| CLE | 1st | 9:31 | 1st | 10 | CLE 13 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Gary Barnidge | 0-7 | |
| CLE | 1st | 9:29 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 13 | Isaiah Crowell -1 yard Rushing Attempt Julian Stanford | 0-7 | -0.1 |
| NYJ | 1st | 8:02 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Robbie Chosen Jamar Taylor | 0-7 | |
| NYJ | 1st | 7:56 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 40 | Matt Forte -2 yard Rushing Attempt Demario Davis | 0-7 | -0.2 |
| CLE | 1st | 6:53 | 1st | 10 | CLE 18 | Terrelle Pryor 35 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darrelle Revis | 0-7 | 3.5 |
| CLE | 1st | 6:17 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 47 | Duke Johnson -3 yard Rushing Attempt Leonard Williams | 0-7 | -0.3 |
| CLE | 1st | 4:27 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 31 | Jordan Payton 3 yard Passing Completion from Kevin Hogan Rontez Miles | 0-7 | 0.3 |
| NYJ | 1st | 3:11 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 13 | Brandon Bostick 4 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Christian Kirksey | 0-10 | 0.4 |
| CLE | 1st | 1:35 | 1st | 10 | CLE 25 | -6 yard Sack Danny Shelton | 0-10 | 1 |
| NYJ | 1st | 0:40 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 29 | Matt Forte 3 yard Rushing Attempt Demario Davis | 0-10 | 0.3 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 14:22 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 45 | Matt Forte 2 yard Rushing Attempt Christian Kirksey | 0-10 | 0.2 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 12:58 | 1st | 10 | CLE 35 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Bilal Powell Carl Nassib | 0-10 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 12:55 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 35 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Bilal Powell | 0-10 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 12:51 | 3rd | 10 | CLE 35 | Bilal Powell 35 yard Rushing TD | 6-10 | 9.5 |
| CLE | 2nd | 12:44 | 1st | 10 | CLE 25 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Ricardo Louis | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 12:38 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 25 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Ricardo Louis | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 12:38 | 3rd | 10 | CLE 25 | Duke Johnson 4 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Mike Catapano | 7-10 | 0.4 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 11:40 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 34 | Matt Forte -4 yard Rushing Attempt Christian Kirksey | 7-10 | -0.4 |
| CLE | 2nd | 10:39 | 1st | 10 | CLE 28 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Terrelle Pryor | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 10:34 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 28 | Terrelle Pryor 8 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darrelle Revis | 7-10 | 0.8 |
| CLE | 2nd | 9:26 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 49 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Terrelle Pryor | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 9:21 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 49 | Gary Barnidge Passing Completion from Josh McCown David Harris | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 8:55 | 3rd | 10 | NYJ 49 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Terrelle Pryor | 7-10 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 8:43 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 15 | Matt Forte 15 yard Rushing Attempt Christian Kirksey | 7-10 | 1.5 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 8:03 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 30 | Matt Forte 2 yard Rushing Attempt Demario Davis | 7-10 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 2nd | 6:31 | 1st | 10 | CLE 30 | Isaiah Crowell Rushing Attempt Jarvis Jenkins | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 6:01 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 30 | Terrelle Pryor 9 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darrelle Revis | 7-10 | 0.9 |
| CLE | 2nd | 4:46 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 45 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Terrelle Pryor | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 4:41 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 45 | Isaiah Crowell 18 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Calvin Pryor | 7-10 | 1.8 |
| CLE | 2nd | 4:01 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 27 | Terrelle Pryor 10 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darrelle Revis | 7-10 | 1 |
| CLE | 2nd | 3:24 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 17 | Josh McCown 3 yard Rushing Attempt | 7-10 | 0.3 |
| CLE | 2nd | 1:51 | 1st | 10 | CLE 25 | Sack Tyrone Holmes | 7-17 | 2 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 1:43 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 25 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Quincy Enunwa Derrick Kindred | 7-17 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 1:39 | 3rd | 10 | NYJ 25 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Quincy Enunwa | 7-17 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 1:25 | 1st | 10 | CLE 42 | Duke Johnson 32 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown David Harris | 7-17 | 3.2 |
| CLE | 2nd | 0:55 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 26 | Duke Johnson 16 yard Rushing Attempt Marcus Gilchrist | 7-17 | 1.6 |
| CLE | 2nd | 0:47 | 1st | Goal | NYJ 10 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Andrew Hawkins | 7-17 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 0:43 | 2nd | Goal | CLE 10 | -6 yard Sack Muhammad Wilkerson | 7-17 | 2 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 14:55 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 22 | Matt Forte 5 yard Rushing Attempt Tracy Howard | 7-20 | 0.5 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 13:27 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 32 | Bilal Powell -1 yard Rushing Attempt Emmanuel Ogbah | 7-20 | -0.1 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 12:11 | 1st | 10 | CLE 49 | Matt Forte 1 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Joe Schobert | 7-20 | 0.1 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 10:23 | 1st | 10 | CLE 37 | Matt Forte 6 yard Rushing Attempt Christian Kirksey | 7-20 | 0.6 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 9:44 | 1st | 10 | CLE 25 | Matt Forte 1 yard Rushing Attempt Jamie Meder | 7-20 | 0.1 |
| CLE | 3rd | 8:15 | 1st | 10 | CLE 25 | Isaiah Crowell Rushing Attempt Lorenzo Mauldin | 14-20 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 7:33 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 25 | Seth DeValve 5 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Jordan Jenkins | 14-20 | 0.5 |
| CLE | 3rd | 6:14 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 45 | Isaiah Crowell 11 yard Rushing Attempt Marcus Gilchrist | 14-20 | 1.1 |
| CLE | 3rd | 5:43 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 34 | Josh McCown Rushing Attempt Fumble | 14-20 | -1.3 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 5:14 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 16 | Matt Forte -2 yard Rushing Attempt Emmanuel Ogbah | 14-20 | -0.2 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 3:49 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 30 | Quincy Enunwa 57 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Jamar Taylor | 14-20 | 5.7 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 3:07 | 1st | 10 | CLE 13 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Brandon Marshall | 14-20 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 3:03 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 13 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Quincy Enunwa | 14-20 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 2:59 | 3rd | 10 | CLE 13 | Robbie Chosen 9 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Tramon Williams | 14-20 | 0.9 |
| CLE | 3rd | 2:05 | 1st | 10 | CLE 19 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Andrew Hawkins | 21-20 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 1:58 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 19 | Isaiah Crowell 3 yard Rushing Attempt Marcus Williams | 21-20 | 0.3 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 1:05 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 19 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Brandon Marshall | 21-20 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 1:00 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 19 | Matt Forte 6 yard Rushing Attempt Tracy Howard | 21-20 | 0.6 |
| NYJ | 4th | 15:00 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 36 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Quincy Enunwa | 21-20 | |
| NYJ | 4th | 14:56 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 36 | Bilal Powell 9 yard Rushing Attempt Christian Kirksey | 21-20 | 0.9 |
| NYJ | 4th | 13:55 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 46 | Matt Forte 6 yard Rushing Attempt Jamie Meder | 21-20 | 0.6 |
| NYJ | 4th | 12:34 | 1st | 10 | CLE 42 | Bilal Powell 20 yard Rushing Attempt Derrick Kindred | 21-20 | 2 |
| NYJ | 4th | 11:53 | 1st | 10 | CLE 22 | Matt Forte 5 yard Rushing Attempt Derrick Kindred | 21-20 | 0.5 |
| CLE | 4th | 9:38 | 1st | 10 | CLE 25 | Isaiah Crowell 5 yard Rushing Attempt Marcus Gilchrist | 28-20 | 0.5 |
| NYJ | 4th | 9:03 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 24 | Matt Forte Rushing Attempt Danny Shelton | 28-20 | |
| NYJ | 4th | 8:21 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 24 | Brandon Marshall 31 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick | 28-20 | 3.1 |
| NYJ | 4th | 7:35 | 1st | 10 | CLE 45 | Matt Forte -1 yard Rushing Attempt Xavier Cooper | 28-20 | -0.1 |
| CLE | 4th | 4:00 | 1st | 10 | CLE 16 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Duke Johnson | 31-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 3:53 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 16 | Gary Barnidge 10 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Marcus Williams | 31-20 | 1 |
| CLE | 4th | 3:25 | 1st | 10 | CLE 26 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Ricardo Louis | 31-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 3:19 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 26 | Duke Johnson Rushing Attempt Darrelle Revis | 31-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 2:45 | 3rd | 10 | CLE 26 | Duke Johnson 17 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darrelle Revis | 31-20 | 1.7 |
| CLE | 4th | 2:11 | 1st | 10 | CLE 43 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Andrew Hawkins | 31-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 2:06 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 43 | Ricardo Louis 7 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Darrelle Revis | 31-20 | 0.7 |
| CLE | 4th | 1:34 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 44 | Duke Johnson 26 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Calvin Pryor | 31-20 | 2.6 |
| CLE | 4th | 1:07 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 18 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Gary Barnidge Darrelle Revis | 31-20 | |
| CLE | 4th | 1:00 | 2nd | 10 | NYJ 18 | Isaiah Crowell 16 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Rontez Miles | 31-20 | 1.6 |
| NYJ | 4th | 0:12 | 1st | 10 | NYJ 44 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Rushing Attempt | 31-28 | |
| CLE | 1st | 8:46 | 3rd | 11 | CLE 12 | Andrew Hawkins 7 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Calvin Pryor | 0-7 | 0.7 |
| CLE | 1st | 4:58 | 3rd | 11 | NYJ 48 | Andrew Hawkins 17 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Marcus Gilchrist | 0-7 | 1.7 |
| NYJ | 1st | 2:25 | 3rd | 11 | NYJ 12 | Charone Peake 13 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Tramon Williams | 0-10 | 1.3 |
| NYJ | 1st | 0:50 | 2nd | 11 | NYJ 24 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Brandon Marshall Joe Haden | 0-10 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 12:48 | 2nd | 11 | NYJ 31 | Brandon Marshall 20 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Ibraheim Campbell | 7-20 | 2 |
| NYJ | 4th | 6:52 | 2nd | 11 | CLE 46 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Brandon Marshall Joe Haden | 28-20 | |
| NYJ | 1st | 7:10 | 3rd | 12 | NYJ 38 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Robbie Chosen Jamar Taylor | 0-7 | |
| CLE | 1st | 7:05 | 4th | 12 | CLE 38 | Duke Johnson 13 yard Punt Return Attempt Charone Peake | 0-7 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 4:35 | 2nd | 12 | NYJ 14 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Brandon Marshall | 14-20 | |
| NYJ | 3rd | 4:31 | 3rd | 12 | NYJ 14 | Robbie Chosen 16 yard Passing Completion from Ryan Fitzpatrick Jamar Taylor | 14-20 | 1.6 |
| CLE | 1st | 5:39 | 2nd | 13 | Midfield | Duke Johnson 2 yard Passing Completion from Josh McCown Julian Stanford | 0-7 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 3rd | 5:29 | 2nd | 13 | NYJ 37 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Randall Telfer | 14-20 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 5:24 | 3rd | 13 | NYJ 37 | Josh McCown Incomplete Pass to Ricardo Louis Darryl Roberts | 14-20 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 10:59 | 2nd | 14 | NYJ 30 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Matt Forte Carl Nassib | 7-10 | |
| NYJ | 2nd | 10:55 | 3rd | 14 | NYJ 30 | Ryan Fitzpatrick Incomplete Pass to Quincy Enunwa | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 10:50 | 4th | 14 | CLE 30 | Duke Johnson 15 yard Punt Return Attempt Taiwan Jones | 7-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 0:38 | 3rd | Goal | NYJ 16 | Josh McCown 7 yard Rushing Attempt Leonard Williams | 7-17 | 0.7 |
| NYJ | 4th | 6:47 | 3rd | 16 | NYJ 49 | Bilal Powell -2 yard Rushing Attempt Derrick Kindred | 28-20 | -0.2 |
| NYJ | 4th | 6:18 | 3rd | 18 | NYJ 47 | Matt Forte 4 yard Rushing Attempt Tyrone Holmes | 28-20 | 0.4 |