| Team | | Time | Down | Distance | Pos | Description | Score | Max Pts |
|---|
| CLE | 1st | 14:57 | 1st | 10 | CLE 8 | Willis McGahee 2 yard Rushing Attempt Kyle Williams | 0-0 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 1st | 14:05 | 1st | 10 | CLE 32 | Fred Jackson 2 yard Rushing Attempt T.J. Ward | 0-0 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 1st | 13:16 | 1st | 10 | CLE 1 | Fred Jackson 1 yard Rushing TD | 6-0 | 6.1 |
| CLE | 1st | 13:13 | 1st | 10 | CLE 10 | Davone Bess 12 yard Passing Completion from Brian Hoyer | 7-0 | 1.2 |
| CLE | 1st | 12:55 | 1st | 10 | CLE 22 | Davone Bess 13 yard Passing Completion from Brian Hoyer Da'Norris Searcy | 7-0 | 1.3 |
| CLE | 1st | 12:15 | 1st | 10 | CLE 35 | Willis McGahee 1 yard Rushing Attempt Marcell Dareus | 7-0 | 0.1 |
| CLE | 1st | 11:32 | 1st | 10 | CLE 47 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Josh Gordon | 7-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 10:05 | 1st | 10 | BUF 10 | Scott Chandler 5 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Paul Kruger | 7-0 | 0.5 |
| BUF | 1st | 9:20 | 1st | 10 | BUF 35 | Tashard Choice 5 yard Rushing Attempt Ahtyba Rubin | 7-0 | 0.5 |
| BUF | 1st | 8:25 | 1st | 10 | BUF 46 | Fred Jackson 4 yard Rushing Attempt T.J. Ward | 7-0 | 0.4 |
| BUF | 1st | 7:22 | 1st | 10 | CLE 37 | -9 yard Sack | 7-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 5:51 | 1st | 10 | CLE 20 | Josh Gordon 15 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Aaron Williams | 10-0 | 1.5 |
| CLE | 1st | 5:30 | 1st | 10 | CLE 35 | Chris Ogbonnaya 7 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Kiko Alonso | 10-0 | 0.7 |
| BUF | 1st | 3:37 | 1st | 10 | BUF 25 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Robert Woods | 10-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 3:05 | 1st | 10 | BUF 36 | Fred Jackson 2 yard Rushing Attempt Phillip Taylor | 10-0 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 1st | 1:36 | 1st | 10 | BUF 31 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Willis McGahee | 10-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 0:35 | 1st | 10 | BUF 12 | -4 yard Sack | 10-0 | |
| BUF | 2nd | 14:00 | 1st | 10 | BUF 12 | C.J. Spiller Rushing Attempt | 10-3 | |
| BUF | 2nd | 12:12 | 1st | 10 | BUF 30 | Fred Jackson Rushing Attempt Craig Robertson | 10-3 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 14:55 | 1st | 10 | CLE 26 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Chris Ogbonnaya | 10-3 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 9:54 | 1st | 10 | CLE 47 | Willis McGahee 6 yard Rushing Attempt Manny Lawson | 10-3 | 0.6 |
| CLE | 2nd | 8:45 | 1st | 10 | BUF 39 | Josh Gordon 16 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Aaron Williams | 10-3 | 1.6 |
| CLE | 2nd | 8:15 | 1st | 10 | BUF 23 | Willis McGahee 11 yard Rushing Attempt Da'Norris Searcy | 10-3 | 1.1 |
| CLE | 2nd | 7:40 | 1st | 10 | BUF 12 | Willis McGahee 6 yard Rushing Attempt Jim Leonhard | 10-3 | 0.6 |
| BUF | 2nd | 3:52 | 1st | 10 | BUF 20 | Fred Jackson 4 yard Rushing Attempt Ahtyba Rubin | 10-10 | 0.4 |
| BUF | 2nd | 2:20 | 1st | 10 | BUF 20 | Fred Jackson 2 yard Rushing Attempt Desmond Bryant | 10-17 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 2nd | 1:46 | 1st | 10 | BUF 16 | Fred Jackson 5 yard Rushing Attempt D'Qwell Jackson | 10-17 | 0.5 |
| BUF | 2nd | 0:43 | 1st | 10 | BUF 30 | Robert Woods 7 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Chris Owens | 10-17 | 0.7 |
| CLE | 2nd | 0:17 | 1st | 10 | CLE 24 | Brandon Weeden -1 yard Rushing Attempt | 10-17 | -0.1 |
| BUF | 3rd | 15:00 | 1st | 10 | BUF 20 | C.J. Spiller 2 yard Rushing Attempt Ahtyba Rubin | 10-17 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 3rd | 13:51 | 1st | 10 | BUF 46 | C.J. Spiller 54 yard Rushing TD | 16-17 | 13.4 |
| CLE | 3rd | 13:51 | 1st | 10 | CLE 20 | Willis McGahee -2 yard Rushing Attempt Mario Williams | 17-17 | -0.2 |
| BUF | 3rd | 11:47 | 1st | 10 | BUF 46 | Fred Jackson 2 yard Rushing Attempt Barkevious Mingo | 17-17 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 3rd | 10:49 | 1st | 10 | CLE 40 | Fred Jackson 5 yard Rushing Attempt Ahtyba Rubin | 17-17 | 0.5 |
| BUF | 3rd | 9:50 | 1st | 10 | CLE 29 | C.J. Spiller 3 yard Rushing Attempt Paul Kruger | 17-17 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 3rd | 8:20 | 1st | 10 | CLE 13 | Tashard Choice 4 yard Rushing Attempt Phillip Taylor | 17-17 | 0.4 |
| BUF | 3rd | 6:32 | 1st | Goal | CLE 1 | Fred Jackson 1 yard Rushing TD | 23-17 | 6.1 |
| CLE | 3rd | 6:00 | 1st | 5 | CLE 31 | Greg Little 47 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Aaron Williams | 24-17 | 4.7 |
| CLE | 3rd | 5:35 | 1st | 25 | BUF 37 | Josh Gordon 37 yard Passing TD from Brandon Weeden | 24-23 | 9.7 |
| BUF | 3rd | 5:35 | 1st | 10 | BUF 20 | C.J. Spiller 2 yard Rushing Attempt John Hughes | 24-24 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 3rd | 4:52 | 1st | 10 | CLE 39 | Willis McGahee 3 yard Rushing Attempt Kiko Alonso | 24-24 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 3rd | 3:25 | 1st | 10 | BUF 11 | C.J. Spiller Rushing Attempt | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 2:05 | 1st | 10 | BUF 32 | Willis McGahee 4 yard Rushing Attempt Manny Lawson | 24-24 | 0.4 |
| CLE | 3rd | 0:45 | 1st | 10 | BUF 12 | Willis McGahee Rushing Attempt Arthur Moats | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 4th | 14:08 | 1st | Goal | BUF 1 | Willis McGahee -1 yard Rushing Attempt Kyle Williams | 24-24 | -0.1 |
| BUF | 4th | 12:25 | 1st | 10 | BUF 19 | Fred Jackson Rushing Attempt Craig Robertson | 24-27 | |
| CLE | 4th | 11:15 | 1st | 10 | CLE 33 | Willis McGahee 4 yard Rushing Attempt Kyle Williams | 24-27 | 0.4 |
| CLE | 4th | 10:24 | 1st | 10 | BUF 49 | Willis McGahee 2 yard Rushing Attempt Kyle Williams | 24-27 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 4th | 8:45 | 1st | 10 | BUF 7 | Chris Hogan 9 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel Buster Skrine | 24-27 | 0.9 |
| BUF | 4th | 7:55 | 1st | 10 | BUF 19 | C.J. Spiller 2 yard Rushing Attempt Ishmaa'ily Kitchen | 24-27 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 4th | 6:38 | 1st | 20 | CLE 33 | Bobby Rainey -5 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Manny Lawson | 24-27 | -0.25 |
| CLE | 4th | 4:44 | 1st | 10 | BUF 47 | Greg Little 16 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Leodis McKelvin | 24-27 | 1.6 |
| CLE | 4th | 4:20 | 1st | 10 | BUF 31 | Willis McGahee 2 yard Rushing Attempt Arthur Moats | 24-27 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 4th | 2:19 | 1st | 10 | BUF 20 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Chris Hogan | 24-30 | |
| BUF | 4th | 2:00 | 1st | 10 | BUF 33 | Chris Hogan 7 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel Joe Haden | 24-30 | 0.7 |
| BUF | 4th | 1:44 | 1st | 10 | BUF 20 | Fred Jackson 12 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel Phillip Taylor | 24-37 | 1.2 |
| BUF | 4th | 1:01 | 1st | 10 | BUF 49 | -4 yard Sack | 24-37 | |
| CLE | 4th | 0:10 | 1st | 10 | CLE 42 | Brandon Weeden -1 yard Rushing Attempt | 24-37 | -0.1 |
| CLE | 1st | 14:35 | 2nd | 8 | CLE 10 | Brian Hoyer Incomplete Pass to Josh Gordon | 0-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 11:03 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 47 | Willis McGahee 3 yard Rushing Attempt Kiko Alonso | 7-0 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 1st | 9:51 | 2nd | 5 | BUF 15 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Lee Smith | 7-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 8:50 | 2nd | 5 | BUF 40 | Steve Johnson 6 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel D'Qwell Jackson | 7-0 | 0.6 |
| BUF | 1st | 8:00 | 2nd | 6 | Midfield | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Steve Johnson | 7-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 4:15 | 2nd | 3 | CLE 42 | Willis McGahee -4 yard Rushing Attempt | 10-0 | -0.4 |
| BUF | 1st | 3:32 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 25 | Fred Jackson 11 yard Rushing Attempt Buster Skrine | 10-0 | 1.1 |
| BUF | 1st | 2:41 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 38 | Tashard Choice 6 yard Rushing Attempt Joe Haden | 10-0 | 0.6 |
| CLE | 1st | 1:31 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 31 | Willis McGahee 6 yard Rushing Attempt Corbin Bryant | 10-0 | 0.6 |
| CLE | 1st | 0:17 | 2nd | 14 | BUF 16 | Bobby Rainey 1 yard Rushing Attempt Aaron Williams | 10-0 | 0.1 |
| BUF | 2nd | 13:15 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 12 | C.J. Spiller 3 yard Rushing Attempt John Hughes | 10-3 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 2nd | 11:50 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 30 | Robert Woods 6 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Buster Skrine | 10-3 | 0.6 |
| CLE | 2nd | 10:58 | 2nd | 10 | CLE 26 | Willis McGahee 2 yard Rushing Attempt Marcell Dareus | 10-3 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 2nd | 9:20 | 2nd | 4 | BUF 47 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Greg Little | 10-3 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 6:35 | 2nd | 1 | BUF 3 | Willis McGahee Rushing Attempt Kyle Williams | 10-3 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 4:45 | 2nd | Goal | BUF 1 | Willis McGahee Rushing Attempt Da'Norris Searcy | 10-3 | |
| BUF | 2nd | 3:25 | 2nd | 6 | BUF 24 | Fred Jackson 3 yard Rushing Attempt Craig Robertson | 10-10 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 2nd | 2:00 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 22 | Fred Jackson 9 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel T.J. Ward | 10-17 | 0.9 |
| BUF | 2nd | 1:12 | 2nd | 5 | BUF 21 | Fred Jackson 9 yard Rushing Attempt Desmond Bryant | 10-17 | 0.9 |
| BUF | 2nd | 0:37 | 2nd | 3 | BUF 37 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Chris Hogan | 10-17 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 14:41 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 22 | Robert Woods 24 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Tashaun Gipson | 10-17 | 2.4 |
| CLE | 3rd | 13:30 | 2nd | 12 | CLE 18 | Gary Barnidge 2 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Marcell Dareus | 17-17 | 0.2 |
| BUF | 3rd | 10:49 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 48 | Robert Woods 12 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Buster Skrine | 17-17 | 1.2 |
| BUF | 3rd | 10:16 | 2nd | 5 | CLE 35 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Robert Woods | 17-17 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 9:14 | 2nd | 7 | CLE 26 | -1 yard Sack | 17-17 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 7:33 | 2nd | 6 | CLE 9 | Tashard Choice 1 yard Rushing Attempt Ahtyba Rubin | 17-17 | 0.1 |
| BUF | 3rd | 5:12 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 22 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Robert Woods | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 4:25 | 2nd | 7 | CLE 42 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Davone Bess | 24-24 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 3:00 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 11 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Robert Woods | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 1:45 | 2nd | 6 | BUF 28 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Josh Gordon | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 4th | 15:00 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 12 | Willis McGahee 9 yard Rushing Attempt Manny Lawson | 24-24 | 0.9 |
| CLE | 4th | 13:45 | 2nd | Goal | BUF 2 | Willis McGahee -4 yard Rushing Attempt Manny Lawson | 24-24 | -0.4 |
| BUF | 4th | 11:59 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 19 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Robert Woods | 24-27 | |
| CLE | 4th | 9:39 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 47 | Sack | 24-27 | |
| BUF | 4th | 8:20 | 2nd | 1 | BUF 16 | Fred Jackson 3 yard Rushing Attempt Ahtyba Rubin | 24-27 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 4th | 7:34 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 21 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Robert Woods | 24-27 | |
| CLE | 4th | 5:55 | 2nd | 25 | CLE 28 | Bobby Rainey 7 yard Rushing Attempt Leodis McKelvin | 24-27 | 0.7 |
| CLE | 4th | 3:25 | 2nd | 8 | BUF 29 | Willis McGahee 3 yard Rushing Attempt Mario Williams | 24-27 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 4th | 2:14 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 20 | Fred Jackson 13 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel T.J. Ward | 24-30 | 1.3 |
| CLE | 4th | 1:44 | 2nd | 3 | BUF 40 | T.J. Ward 44 yard INT Return TD | 24-36 | 10 |
| BUF | 4th | 1:19 | 2nd | 10 | BUF 32 | Fred Jackson 6 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel Buster Skrine | 24-37 | 0.6 |
| BUF | 4th | 0:51 | 2nd | 14 | BUF 45 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Marcus Easley | 24-37 | |
| CLE | 1st | 14:24 | 3rd | 8 | CLE 10 | Brian Hoyer Incomplete Pass to Greg Little | 0-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 10:30 | 3rd | 7 | Midfield | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Jordan Cameron | 7-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 9:36 | 3rd | 5 | BUF 15 | Scott Chandler 20 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Chris Owens | 7-0 | 2 |
| BUF | 1st | 7:48 | 3rd | 6 | Midfield | Steve Johnson 13 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Tashaun Gipson | 7-0 | 1.3 |
| BUF | 1st | 6:25 | 3rd | 7 | CLE 34 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Trevor Graham | 7-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 4:15 | 3rd | 7 | CLE 38 | -6 yard Sack | 10-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 2:10 | 3rd | 2 | BUF 44 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Chris Hogan | 10-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 1:02 | 3rd | 4 | BUF 25 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Davone Bess | 10-0 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 11:02 | 3rd | 13 | BUF 15 | Jordan Cameron 3 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Manny Lawson | 10-0 | 0.3 |
| BUF | 2nd | 12:44 | 3rd | 7 | BUF 15 | Robert Woods 15 yard Passing Completion from E.J. Manuel Tashaun Gipson | 10-3 | 1.5 |
| BUF | 2nd | 11:35 | 3rd | 4 | BUF 36 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Trevor Graham | 10-3 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 10:33 | 3rd | 8 | CLE 28 | Jordan Cameron 19 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Jerry Hughes | 10-3 | 1.9 |
| CLE | 2nd | 9:13 | 3rd | 4 | BUF 47 | Greg Little 8 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Da'Norris Searcy | 10-3 | 0.8 |
| CLE | 2nd | 5:54 | 3rd | 1 | BUF 3 | Willis McGahee 2 yard Rushing Attempt Alan Branch | 10-3 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 2nd | 3:52 | 3rd | Goal | BUF 1 | Willis McGahee 1 yard Rushing TD | 10-9 | 6.1 |
| BUF | 2nd | 2:52 | 3rd | 3 | BUF 27 | E.J. Manuel Incomplete Pass to Scott Chandler | 10-10 | |
| BUF | 2nd | 0:33 | 3rd | 3 | BUF 37 | Fred Jackson -1 yard Rushing Attempt Phillip Taylor | 10-17 | -0.1 |
| CLE | 3rd | 13:15 | 3rd | 10 | CLE 20 | -6 yard Sack | 17-17 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 10:04 | 3rd | 5 | CLE 35 | Tashard Choice 6 yard Rushing Attempt Barkevious Mingo | 17-17 | 0.6 |
| BUF | 3rd | 8:29 | 3rd | 8 | CLE 27 | E.J. Manuel 14 yard Rushing Attempt Tashaun Gipson | 17-17 | 1.4 |
| BUF | 3rd | 5:02 | 3rd | 8 | BUF 22 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Scott Chandler | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 4:10 | 3rd | 12 | CLE 37 | Brandon Weeden Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Fumble recovered by Joe Thomas Jerry Hughes | 24-24 | -1 |
| BUF | 3rd | 2:51 | 3rd | 10 | BUF 11 | -7 yard Sack | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 1:27 | 3rd | 6 | BUF 28 | Willis McGahee 16 yard Rushing Attempt Da'Norris Searcy | 24-24 | 1.6 |
| CLE | 4th | 14:41 | 3rd | 1 | BUF 3 | Brandon Weeden 2 yard Rushing Attempt Kiko Alonso | 24-24 | 0.2 |
| CLE | 4th | 13:00 | 3rd | Goal | BUF 6 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Jordan Cameron | 24-24 | |
| BUF | 4th | 11:53 | 3rd | 10 | BUF 19 | Trevor Graham 9 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel D'Qwell Jackson | 24-27 | 0.9 |
| CLE | 4th | 8:56 | 3rd | 15 | CLE 46 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass | 24-27 | |
| BUF | 4th | 7:20 | 3rd | 8 | BUF 21 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Robert Woods | 24-27 | |
| CLE | 4th | 5:29 | 3rd | 18 | CLE 35 | Josh Gordon 18 yard Passing Completion from Brandon Weeden Aaron Williams | 24-27 | 1.8 |
| CLE | 4th | 2:40 | 3rd | 5 | BUF 26 | Brandon Weeden Incomplete Pass to Willis McGahee | 24-27 | |
| BUF | 4th | 1:14 | 3rd | 4 | BUF 38 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Trevor Graham | 24-37 | |
| BUF | 4th | 0:44 | 3rd | 14 | BUF 45 | Scott Chandler 13 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel D'Qwell Jackson | 24-37 | 1.3 |
| CLE | 1st | 14:14 | 4th | 8 | CLE 10 | Jim Leonhard 47 yard Punt Return Attempt Chris Owens | 0-0 | |
| CLE | 1st | 10:12 | 4th | 7 | Midfield | Jim Leonhard 40 yard Punt Return Attempt | 7-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 5:51 | 4th | 7 | CLE 34 | Dan Carpenter 52 yard Field Goal Made | 10-0 | 6 |
| CLE | 1st | 3:55 | 4th | 13 | CLE 32 | Jim Leonhard 43 yard Punt Return Attempt | 10-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 1:58 | 4th | 2 | BUF 44 | Travis Benjamin 44 yard Punt Return Attempt Shawn Powell | 10-0 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 14:24 | 4th | 10 | BUF 12 | Billy Cundiff 30 yard Field Goal Made | 10-3 | 3 |
| BUF | 2nd | 11:21 | 4th | 4 | BUF 36 | Travis Benjamin 44 yard Punt Return Attempt Nigel Bradham | 10-3 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 2:20 | 4th | 3 | BUF 27 | Travis Benjamin 79 yard Punt Return TD | 10-16 | 6 |
| BUF | 2nd | 0:28 | 4th | 9 | BUF 31 | Travis Benjamin 58 yard Punt Return Attempt Garrison Sanborn | 10-17 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 12:25 | 4th | 16 | CLE 14 | Leodis McKelvin 49 yard Punt Return Attempt Barkevious Mingo | 17-17 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 4:57 | 4th | 8 | BUF 22 | Shawn Powell Punt Return Attempt | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 4:00 | 4th | 10 | CLE 39 | Spencer Lanning Punt Return Attempt | 24-24 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 2:29 | 4th | 17 | BUF 4 | Travis Benjamin 34 yard Punt Return Attempt Marcus Dowtin | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 4th | 12:31 | 4th | Goal | BUF 6 | Billy Cundiff 24 yard Field Goal Made | 24-27 | 3 |
| BUF | 4th | 11:31 | 4th | 1 | BUF 28 | Travis Benjamin 44 yard Punt Return Attempt Tashard Choice | 24-27 | |
| CLE | 4th | 8:56 | 4th | 15 | CLE 46 | Spencer Lanning Punt Return Attempt | 24-27 | |
| BUF | 4th | 7:13 | 4th | 8 | BUF 21 | Travis Benjamin 49 yard Punt Return Attempt Jonathan Meeks | 24-27 | |
| CLE | 4th | 2:19 | 4th | 5 | BUF 26 | Billy Cundiff 44 yard Field Goal Made | 24-30 | 4 |
| BUF | 4th | 1:08 | 4th | 4 | BUF 38 | Scott Chandler 11 yard Passing Completion from Jeff Tuel D'Qwell Jackson | 24-37 | 1.1 |
| BUF | 4th | 0:20 | 4th | 1 | CLE 42 | Jeff Tuel Incomplete Pass to Fred Jackson | 24-37 | |
| BUF | 1st | 15:00 | | | BUF 35 | Greg Little 0 yard Kick Return Attempt Marcus Easley | 0-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 13:16 | | | CLE 2 | Dan Carpenter XP | 7-0 | 1 |
| BUF | 1st | 13:16 | | | BUF 35 | Greg Little 0 yard Kick Return Attempt Chris Hogan | 7-0 | |
| BUF | 1st | 5:51 | | | BUF 35 | Dan Carpenter Kick Return Attempt | 10-0 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 0:00 | | | CLE 35 | Marcus Easley 0 yard Kick Return Attempt Brandon Magee | 10-3 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 3:52 | | | BUF 2 | Billy Cundiff XP | 10-10 | 1 |
| CLE | 2nd | 3:52 | | | CLE 35 | Billy Cundiff Kick Return Attempt | 10-10 | |
| CLE | 2nd | 2:20 | | | BUF 2 | Billy Cundiff XP | 10-17 | 1 |
| CLE | 2nd | 2:20 | | | CLE 35 | Billy Cundiff Kick Return Attempt | 10-17 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 15:00 | | | CLE 35 | Billy Cundiff Kick Return Attempt | 10-17 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 13:51 | | | CLE 2 | Dan Carpenter XP | 17-17 | 1 |
| BUF | 3rd | 13:51 | | | BUF 35 | Dan Carpenter Kick Return Attempt | 17-17 | |
| BUF | 3rd | 6:32 | | | CLE 2 | Dan Carpenter XP | 24-17 | 1 |
| BUF | 3rd | 6:32 | | | BUF 20 | Greg Little 0 yard Kick Return Attempt Brandon Burton | 24-17 | |
| CLE | 3rd | 5:35 | | | BUF 2 | Billy Cundiff XP | 24-24 | 1 |
| CLE | 3rd | 5:35 | | | CLE 35 | Billy Cundiff Kick Return Attempt | 24-24 | |
| CLE | 4th | 12:31 | | | CLE 35 | Marcus Easley 0 yard Kick Return Attempt Leon McFadden | 24-27 | |
| CLE | 4th | 2:19 | | | CLE 35 | Billy Cundiff Kick Return Attempt | 24-30 | |
| CLE | 4th | 1:44 | | | BUF 2 | Billy Cundiff XP | 24-37 | 1 |