| Team | | Time | Down | Distance | Pos | Description | Score | Max Pts |
|---|
| IND | 3rd | 10:13 | | | NYJ 0 | Donald Brown 1 yard Rushing TD | 10-15 | 6.1 |
| IND | 2nd | 11:46 | | | NYJ 0 | Adam Vinatieri 22 yard Field Goal Made | 0-9 | 3 |
| IND | 1st | 6:55 | | | NYJ 0 | Joseph Addai 21 yard Rushing TD | 0-6 | 8.1 |
| NYJ | 4th | 5:38 | | | NYJ 0 | Braylon Edwards 2 Pt Conversion Passing from Mark Sanchez | 29-15 | 2 |
| NYJ | 4th | 5:38 | | | NYJ 0 | Thomas Jones 1 yard Rushing TD | 27-15 | 6.1 |
| NYJ | 4th | 13:23 | | | NYJ 0 | Jay Feely 43 yard Field Goal Made | 21-15 | 4 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 1:29 | | | NYJ 0 | Dustin Keller 2 Pt Conversion Passing from Mark Sanchez | 18-15 | 2 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 1:29 | | | NYJ 0 | Curtis Painter 1 yard Sack Calvin Pace Fumble Lost recovered by , 1 yard Fumble Return TD | 16-15 | 7 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 14:48 | | | NYJ 0 | Jay Feely XP | 10-9 | 1 |
| NYJ | 3rd | 14:48 | | | IND 0 | Brad Smith 106 yard Kick Return TD | 9-9 | 6 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 1:44 | | | NYJ 0 | Jay Feely 35 yard Field Goal Made | 3-9 | 3 |