I have freeman vs the saints or Matt Ryan vs the giants. Freeman is facing the worst pass defense in the league but Matty ice has been clutch all year. Who should I start?
My problem is Freeman, Luck or Cutler! They just posted today Cutler is out with neck injury there goes that thought and I do not like Luck against Houston after the loss to the Patriots! But Luck is also the same guy who went into Detroit and banged out 391 Yds and 4 TDs getting me 35 points two weeks ago!
Now statistically Freeman should kill the Eagles question is by how much and how well?!?!
Going into Semi Finals with my first shot at a title and a 6 game winning streak! I would be pissed to loose in semi finals!
OK just looked back and Freeman scored 25 points on N.O. weeks ago in there first meeting! he's been relatively consistent all season so I think he gets the start!
That's my question. A-Rodg barely put up 13 the first time around at home. But this game does have more riding on it.. And that's when great players shine. Tough decision.
Playoff game: got RG3 and Freeman against the worst d in the NFL. Freeman put up a nice number last time against the saints. If RG3 plays how mobile will he be? So my question is.... RG3 or Freeman?!
I don't think you really can or should be trying to make this decision on Tuesday. If RGIII goes through practices and looks great this week, I don't know how you reasonably sit him for Josh Freeman. As a backup plan, Freeman is pretty ideal this week, but a healthy RGIII is likely to shred the Browns.
NP. I'm in the same exact predicament, and obviously in a big week, so I've given this a lot of thought myself. Just figured I'd pass along what I've gathered for myself. In essence, RGIII got me this far, so I can't back off now.
Am I crazy to start Freeman over Brady in Week 15? Brady is facing a really tough 49ers D while Freeman is matched up against the worst defense in the league. Thoughts?
Not the craziest idea, though I'd bet the consensus response will be something along the lines of "never sit your studs" and the like. At the same time, it isn't like Freeman's been on fire lately, and he didn't look all that impressive against a pretty bad Eagles D. I probably stick with Tom, personally, but either start is defensible.
I'm just glad I have Freeman in this juicy matchup in case RGIII can't go on Sunday.
Go Brady! Believe it or not I have them 2 also (and Luck) and Im keeping Brady as my #1...Look at the doubts people had with starting him vs Houston and look what he did to them. I say go with him, he almost always puts up above average numbers so its less risky, im assuming your in the playoffs.
I see what you are saying, but the 49ers are a much tougher Defense. I've decided to go with Freeman since he is due for a big game and against a terrible defense at that.
Comments
ahphooeyWed 12/12/12 10:49 AM
Freeman or Payton???
ahphooeyWed 12/19/12 1:08 PM
I guess neither. fml
Ernest_AWed 12/12/12 12:35 AM
Freeman or Ryan ?
HernekerTue 12/11/12 6:26 PM
I have freeman vs the saints or Matt Ryan vs the giants. Freeman is facing the worst pass defense in the league but Matty ice has been clutch all year. Who should I start?
KNIGHTHAWK10Tue 12/11/12 5:28 PM
My problem is Freeman, Luck or Cutler! They just posted today Cutler is out with neck injury there goes that thought and I do not like Luck against Houston after the loss to the Patriots! But Luck is also the same guy who went into Detroit and banged out 391 Yds and 4 TDs getting me 35 points two weeks ago!
Now statistically Freeman should kill the Eagles question is by how much and how well?!?!
Going into Semi Finals with my first shot at a title and a 6 game winning streak! I would be pissed to loose in semi finals!
Any thoughts anyone?
KNIGHTHAWK10Tue 12/11/12 5:30 PM
OOPS!! There actually playing N.O.! Same diff then lol!
KNIGHTHAWK10Tue 12/11/12 5:31 PM
OK just looked back and Freeman scored 25 points on N.O. weeks ago in there first meeting! he's been relatively consistent all season so I think he gets the start!
AndrewSchellerTue 12/11/12 3:48 PM
Freeman v.s. Saints or Rodgers v.s. Bears?
JorgyTue 12/11/12 6:51 PM
That's my question. A-Rodg barely put up 13 the first time around at home. But this game does have more riding on it.. And that's when great players shine. Tough decision.
DTowneWed 12/12/12 12:54 PM
same situation for me as well. I think i may be going with Freeman this week. Rodgers has been kind of disappointing the past couple weeks.
BigDLaffinTue 12/11/12 6:06 AM
Playoff game: got RG3 and Freeman against the worst d in the NFL. Freeman put up a nice number last time against the saints. If RG3 plays how mobile will he be? So my question is.... RG3 or Freeman?!
Greg_WTue 12/11/12 9:56 AM
Freeman for me
JamaliusJacksonTue 12/11/12 12:18 PM
I don't think you really can or should be trying to make this decision on Tuesday. If RGIII goes through practices and looks great this week, I don't know how you reasonably sit him for Josh Freeman. As a backup plan, Freeman is pretty ideal this week, but a healthy RGIII is likely to shred the Browns.
BigDLaffinTue 12/11/12 6:14 PM
If he goes then RG3 it is, thanks for the advice.
JamaliusJacksonTue 12/11/12 7:59 PM
NP. I'm in the same exact predicament, and obviously in a big week, so I've given this a lot of thought myself. Just figured I'd pass along what I've gathered for myself. In essence, RGIII got me this far, so I can't back off now.
JeffSteinbergMon 12/10/12 5:25 PM
Am I crazy to start Freeman over Brady in Week 15? Brady is facing a really tough 49ers D while Freeman is matched up against the worst defense in the league. Thoughts?
MTDaytonMon 12/10/12 6:49 PM
im doing it...yolo
JamaliusJacksonMon 12/10/12 7:46 PM
Not the craziest idea, though I'd bet the consensus response will be something along the lines of "never sit your studs" and the like. At the same time, it isn't like Freeman's been on fire lately, and he didn't look all that impressive against a pretty bad Eagles D. I probably stick with Tom, personally, but either start is defensible.
I'm just glad I have Freeman in this juicy matchup in case RGIII can't go on Sunday.
lefties1Mon 12/10/12 8:58 PM
that's the same for me. freeman will have a 20+ point game for sure, which is all i need
Greg_WTue 12/11/12 9:58 AM
Why is that all you need, do you have studs at every position?
lefties1Tue 12/11/12 5:57 PM
well I have Julio Jones, Arian Foster, and Doug Martin, and when they're hot I usually win, so if they have a good week, all I need is 20 from freeman
warriors2185Wed 12/12/12 3:01 AM
Go Brady! Believe it or not I have them 2 also (and Luck) and Im keeping Brady as my #1...Look at the doubts people had with starting him vs Houston and look what he did to them. I say go with him, he almost always puts up above average numbers so its less risky, im assuming your in the playoffs.
JeffSteinbergWed 12/12/12 8:17 AM
I see what you are saying, but the 49ers are a much tougher Defense. I've decided to go with Freeman since he is due for a big game and against a terrible defense at that.