| Team | Time | | Description | Score | Max Pts |
|---|
| COL | Top 1 | 0 | Charlie Blackmon Single, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-0 | 1 |
| COL | Top 1 | 0 | DJ LeMahieu Sacrifice Hit, Charlie Blackmon to 2nd, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-0 | 1 |
| COL | Top 1 | 1 | Nolan Arenado Single, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 1 | 0 | Jacoby Ellsbury Out Trevor Story, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 1 | 1 | Brett Gardner Walk, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 1 | 1 | Carlos Beltrán Out Jon Gray, Mark Reynolds, Brett Gardner to 2nd, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-0 | 1 |
| COL | Top 2 | 1 | Ryan Raburn Out Didi Gregorius, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-0 | 1 |
| COL | Top 2 | 2 | Mark Reynolds Out Jacoby Ellsbury, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Brian McCann Walk, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Starlin Castro Single, Brian McCann to 2nd, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Didi Gregorius Walk, Starlin Castro to 2nd, Brian McCann to 3rd, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Rob Refsnyder Out Brandon Barnes, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 2 | Brett Gardner Out Brandon Barnes, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 3 | 0 | Nick Hundley Single, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 3 | 0 | DJ LeMahieu Out Rob Refsnyder, Chase Headley, Starlin Castro, Charlie Blackmon to 2nd, pitcher CC Sabathia | 2-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 3 | 1 | Nolan Arenado Out Rob Refsnyder, Didi Gregorius, Charlie Blackmon to 3rd, pitcher CC Sabathia | 2-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 3 | 2 | Carlos González Out Brett Gardner, pitcher CC Sabathia | 2-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 0 | Carlos Beltrán Out Mark Reynolds, DJ LeMahieu, pitcher Jon Gray | 2-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 1 | Alex Rodriguez Single, pitcher Jon Gray | 2-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 2 | Starlin Castro Out Mark Reynolds, pitcher Jon Gray | 2-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 4 | 0 | Trevor Story Walk, pitcher CC Sabathia | 2-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 4 | 1 | Mark Reynolds Single, Trevor Story to 3rd, pitcher CC Sabathia | 2-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 4 | 1 | Brandon Barnes Single, pitcher CC Sabathia | 5-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 4 | 1 | Charlie Blackmon Out Jacoby Ellsbury, pitcher CC Sabathia | 5-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 4 | 2 | DJ LeMahieu Out Jacoby Ellsbury, pitcher CC Sabathia | 5-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 0 | Didi Gregorius Out Mark Reynolds, DJ LeMahieu, pitcher Jon Gray | 5-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 1 | Chase Headley Out Mark Reynolds, pitcher Jon Gray | 5-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 2 | Rob Refsnyder Walk, pitcher Jon Gray | 5-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 2 | Jacoby Ellsbury Out Mark Reynolds, pitcher Jon Gray | 5-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 5 | 0 | Nolan Arenado Walk, pitcher CC Sabathia | 5-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 5 | 2 | Nick Hundley Out Rob Refsnyder, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Anthony Swarzak | 8-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 0 | Brett Gardner Walk, pitcher Jon Gray | 8-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 1 | Brian McCann Out Jordan Lyles, Trevor Story, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 6 | 1 | Charlie Blackmon Out Rob Refsnyder, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Anthony Swarzak | 8-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 6 | 2 | DJ LeMahieu Out Rob Refsnyder, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Anthony Swarzak | 8-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 6 | 1 | Didi Gregorius Out Brandon Barnes, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 6 | 2 | Chase Headley Out Mark Reynolds, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-4 | 1 |
| COL | Top 7 | 0 | Nolan Arenado Out Rob Refsnyder, pitcher Dellin Betances | 8-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 0 | Jacoby Ellsbury Out Charlie Blackmon, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 1 | Brett Gardner Single, Rob Refsnyder to 2nd, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-4 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 1 | Alex Rodriguez Out Carlos González, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-7 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 2 | Starlin Castro Single, Brian McCann to 3rd, pitcher Miguel Castro | 8-7 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 2 | Chase Headley Walk, Didi Gregorius to 2nd, Starlin Castro to 3rd, pitcher Miguel Castro | 8-8 | 1 |
| COL | Top 8 | 1 | Mark Reynolds Out Rob Refsnyder, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Andrew Miller | 8-8 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 0 | Brett Gardner Out Nolan Arenado, pitcher Gonzalez Germen | 8-8 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 1 | Carlos Beltrán Walk, pitcher Gonzalez Germen | 8-8 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 1 | Alex Rodriguez Out Nick Hundley, pitcher Gonzalez Germen | 8-8 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 2 | Brian McCann Out Mark Reynolds, DJ LeMahieu, pitcher Gonzalez Germen | 8-8 | 1 |
| COL | Top 9 | 1 | Charlie Blackmon Out Aroldis Chapman, Ike Davis, pitcher Aroldis Chapman | 8-8 | 1 |
| COL | Top 1 | 2 | Carlos González Strikeout, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-0 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 1 | 2 | Alex Rodriguez Strikeout, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-0 | 2 |
| COL | Top 2 | 0 | Trevor Story Strikeout, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-0 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 1 | Jacoby Ellsbury Strikeout, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-4 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 1 | Brian McCann Strikeout, pitcher Jon Gray | 2-4 | 2 |
| COL | Top 4 | 0 | Ryan Raburn Strikeout, pitcher CC Sabathia | 2-4 | 2 |
| COL | Top 5 | 1 | Mark Reynolds Strikeout, pitcher Anthony Swarzak | 8-4 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 0 | Alex Rodriguez Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-4 | 2 |
| COL | Top 6 | 0 | Brandon Barnes Strikeout, pitcher Anthony Swarzak | 8-4 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 6 | 0 | Starlin Castro Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-4 | 2 |
| COL | Top 7 | 1 | Carlos González Strikeout, pitcher Dellin Betances | 8-4 | 2 |
| COL | Top 7 | 2 | Trevor Story Strikeout, pitcher Dellin Betances | 8-4 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 2 | Brian McCann Double, pitcher Boone Logan | 8-7 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 2 | Didi Gregorius 1-Run Single, Starlin Castro to 2nd, Brian McCann scores, pitcher Miguel Castro | 8-8 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 2 | Rob Refsnyder Strikeout, pitcher Miguel Castro | 8-8 | 2 |
| COL | Top 8 | 0 | Ryan Raburn Strikeout, pitcher Andrew Miller | 8-8 | 2 |
| COL | Top 8 | 2 | Nick Hundley Strikeout, pitcher Andrew Miller | 8-8 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 0 | Jacoby Ellsbury Double, pitcher Gonzalez Germen | 8-8 | 2 |
| COL | Top 9 | 0 | Brandon Barnes Strikeout, pitcher Aroldis Chapman | 8-8 | 2 |
| COL | Top 9 | 2 | DJ LeMahieu Strikeout, pitcher Aroldis Chapman | 8-8 | 2 |
| COL | Top 3 | 0 | Charlie Blackmon 2-Run Single, Brandon Barnes scores, Nick Hundley scores, pitcher CC Sabathia | 2-4 | 3 |
| COL | Top 5 | 1 | Trevor Story 1-Run Double, Carlos González scores, pitcher Anthony Swarzak | 6-4 | 3 |
| NYY | Bot 9 | 0 | Starlin Castro 1-Run Home Run, pitcher Jason Motte | 8-9 | 7 |
| COL | Top 5 | 1 | Ryan Raburn 2-Run Home Run, Trevor Story scores, pitcher Anthony Swarzak | 8-4 | 8 |
| COL | Top 4 | 1 | Nick Hundley 3-Run Home Run, Mark Reynolds scores, Trevor Story scores, pitcher CC Sabathia | 5-4 | 9 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 1 | Carlos Beltrán 3-Run Home Run, Brett Gardner scores, Rob Refsnyder scores, pitcher Jordan Lyles | 8-7 | 9 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Chase Headley 4-Run Grand Slam, Didi Gregorius scores, Starlin Castro scores, Brian McCann scores, pitcher Jon Gray | 0-4 | 10 |
| COL | Top 3 | 0 | Brandon Barnes Error, Nick Hundley to 3rd, pitcher CC Sabathia | 0-4 | |
| COL | Top 5 | 0 | Carlos González Out, pitcher CC Sabathia | 5-4 | |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 0 | Carlos Beltrán Hit By Pitch, Brett Gardner to 2nd, pitcher Jon Gray | 8-4 | |