 | ||
| Pick | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| 1.1 #1 | RP HOU | |
| 2.1 #13 | 3B SD | |
| 3.1 #25 | OF SF | |
| 3.11 #35 | P CWS | |
| 4.1 #37 | P MIL | |
| 5.1 #49 | C BAL | |
 | ||
| 1.2 #2 | SS WSH | |
| 1.12 #12 | SP BOS | |
| 2.2 #14 | C KC | |
| 2.12 #24 | OF CHC | |
| 3.2 #26 | SS DET | |
| 4.2 #38 | P NYY | |
| 5.2 #50 | C STL | |
 | ||
| 1.3 #3 | 3B CWS | |
| 1.11 #11 | P ATH | |
| 2.3 #15 | P CHC | |
| 3.3 #27 | OF PIT | |
| 4.3 #39 | C DET | |
| 5.3 #51 | P PHI | |
Darth Maul | ||
| 1.4 #4 | P SEA | |
| 2.4 #16 | P BOS | |
| 3.4 #28 | SS MIL | |
| 4.4 #40 | OF PHI | |
| 5.4 #52 | SS TOR | |
 | ||
| 1.5 #5 | 3B TOR | |
| 2.11 #23 | SS SF | |
| 4.12 #48 | OF SEA | |
| 5.12 #60 | OF BAL | |
 | ||
| 1.6 #6 | SS COL | |
| 2.6 #18 | P LAA | |
| 3.6 #30 | OF BOS | |
| 4.6 #42 | SS NYY | |
| 5.6 #54 | C MIA | |
Cranford cougars | ||
| 1.7 #7 | OF NYM | |
| 2.7 #19 | P NYY | |
| 3.7 #31 | P HOU | |
| 3.12 #36 | SS NYM | |
| 4.7 #43 | SS NYY | |
| 5.7 #55 | P BOS | |
Muskie | ||
| 1.8 #8 | P PIT | |
| 2.8 #20 | P SD | |
| 3.8 #32 | SS BOS | |
| 4.8 #44 | OF ARI | |
| 5.8 #56 | OF KC | |
| 5.11 #59 | P CIN | |
 | ||
| 1.9 #9 | P STL | |
| 2.9 #21 | SS MIN | |
| 3.9 #33 | OF STL | |
| 4.9 #45 | 1B NYM | |
| 5.9 #57 | P NYY | |
 | ||
| 1.10 #10 | P SEA | |
| 2.10 #22 | P TB | |
| 3.10 #34 | P PIT | |
| 4.10 #46 | C CLE | |
| 5.10 #58 | P SD | |
Gladiators | ||
| 2.5 #17 | RP TOR | |
| 3.5 #29 | P ATH | |
| 4.5 #41 | P CLE | |
| 4.11 #47 | P TOR | |
| 5.5 #53 | P PHI | |