FleaMod Admin Mon 7/23/12 2:55 PM

We like Freeman better. More downfield potential. Resurrection of a year plus VJax.

Your thoughts?

rangerdave Wed 8/8/12 8:55 PM

Fairly equal this year, but I see more offensive opportunities for Smith in 2012.

eastcoast49er Tue 8/7/12 10:36 AM

Pretty sure the 49ers will make the playoffs (even if it's just from winning the division)... but, as Doe said, Smith is what he is. He has a hard time getting passes down the field with any amount of success. I do think the upgrade at WR will be apparent in his stats though.

ckleinhe Fri 7/27/12 6:18 AM

Freeman has more upside. Smith is what he is.

Sharma19 Wed 7/25/12 10:05 PM

Alex Smith is pretty risky. Alex Smith already used his breakout year for last year and I personally doubt he can repeat, but I may be wrong since they added WR's Mario Manningham and Randy Moss but like you mentioned TB added VJAX. Josh Freeman never had a breakout year yet so this may be his year.

toler89 Tue 7/24/12 11:07 PM

Alex smith is a bumb 1 decent year does not erase all the bad ones. they wont make the playoffs watch.