You have to go with ARod on this one, its a no brainer! He is a top five QB and the packers are a pass first team, plus he doesnt throw alot of INT's. Favre would be second pick because the vikings want to run the ball not pass!
Not going against RJWhite, who is the expert lol, but look at it this way:
Favre is playing against Detroit!!
Eli is playing against the Cowboys
Aaron against the Bengals
The G-men and Cowboys is ALWAYS a bangout fistfight that goes the distance! Hard to pick who D is going to shut down what QB!! With that no Eli!
Aaron is going against a strong Cincy D and might get banged up and throw INT's!! With that Aaron out!
Here is my pick, Favre!! Why?? He's going against the Lions D who can't rush to well and the Viling OL is strong, giving Brett all the time in the world!! I perdict he is going to have a big game!!
Gotta go with Rodgers here. He's a top-five QB overall, while the other two aren't even close. Most weeks, that's going to lead to him being the best of the three.
[Deleted User]Tue 9/15/09 4:08 PM
Favre, Eli Manning, Aaron Rodgers
The_REIMENATORWed 9/16/09 2:07 PM
You have to go with ARod on this one, its a no brainer! He is a top five QB and the packers are a pass first team, plus he doesnt throw alot of INT's. Favre would be second pick because the vikings want to run the ball not pass!
[Deleted User]Wed 9/16/09 1:02 AM
HGD,
Not going against RJWhite, who is the expert lol, but look at it this way:
Favre is playing against Detroit!!
Eli is playing against the Cowboys
Aaron against the Bengals
The G-men and Cowboys is ALWAYS a bangout fistfight that goes the distance! Hard to pick who D is going to shut down what QB!! With that no Eli!
Aaron is going against a strong Cincy D and might get banged up and throw INT's!! With that Aaron out!
Here is my pick, Favre!! Why?? He's going against the Lions D who can't rush to well and the Viling OL is strong, giving Brett all the time in the world!! I perdict he is going to have a big game!!
Sorry, RJWhite, JMO!!
Rick
RJWhiteTue 9/15/09 10:37 PM
Gotta go with Rodgers here. He's a top-five QB overall, while the other two aren't even close. Most weeks, that's going to lead to him being the best of the three.