Doug, Go with Peyton Manning

i played peyton wk4 21.67points. eli 22.73 so it was a push. will see what wk5 brings. thanks all

stick with Peyton

munger,

Tough one and seeing u r asking about both weeks, I will go with Peyton (with a slight chance of Eli) Peyton has weapons to pass to with the coming out of Gason (yes I misspelled but he is the rookie that shined in the last game!) Wayne and Clark!! Indy never much relied on a running game and Peyton puts up big numbers week after week!!

Eli also has young weapons but they are getting hurt and also G-men have the best running game in the NFL right now, taking away the points from Eli and giving them to Jacobs and Bradshaw! But there is the threat of him getting a big game in week 4 with KCs secondary being one of the worst!

With that, flip a coin for week 4, and go with Peyton in with 5 for sure!!

Rick

Eli will do good....but Peyton will do better....as has been said....He throws the ball as if he's playing college teams out there

Always Peyton

NEVER...EVER....bench Peyton!! He is a frickin' beast!!

I would start Eli over Peyton. Eli is playing KC which does not have a good pass defense.