1st |
| Team | | Time | Down | Distance | Pos | Description | Score | Max Pts |
|---|
| CLE | 1st | 9:52 | | | NYJ 0 | Phil Dawson 34 yard Field Goal Made | 0-3 | 3 |
| NYJ | 1st | 5:52 | | | NYJ 0 | Nick Folk 27 yard Field Goal Made | 3-3 | 3 |
| CLE | 1st | 0:16 | | | NYJ 0 | Peyton Hillis 12 yard Rushing TD | 3-9 | 7.2 |
| CLE | 1st | 0:16 | | | NYJ 0 | Phil Dawson XP | 3-10 | 1 |
| NYJ | 1st | 15:00 | | | NYJ 0 | Nick Folk 48 yard Field Goal Missed | 26-20 | |
| NYJ | 1st | 15:00 | | | NYJ 0 | Nick Folk 24 yard Field Goal Missed | 26-20 | |
| NYJ | 1st | 15:00 | | | NYJ 0 | Nick Folk 47 yard Field Goal Missed | 26-20 | |
|
2nd |
| NYJ | 2nd | 11:09 | | | NYJ 0 | Jerricho Cotchery 25 yard Passing TD from Mark Sanchez | 9-10 | 8.5 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 11:09 | | | NYJ 0 | Nick Folk XP | 10-10 | 1 |
| CLE | 2nd | 5:13 | | | NYJ 0 | Phil Dawson 23 yard Field Goal Made | 10-13 | 3 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 0:23 | | | NYJ 0 | Mark Sanchez 1 yard Rushing TD | 16-13 | 6.1 |
| NYJ | 2nd | 0:23 | | | NYJ 0 | Nick Folk XP | 17-13 | 1 |
|
4th |
| NYJ | 4th | 2:42 | | | NYJ 0 | Nick Folk 25 yard Field Goal Made | 20-13 | 3 |
| CLE | 4th | 0:44 | | | NYJ 0 | Mohamed Massaquoi 3 yard Passing TD from Colt McCoy | 20-19 | 6.3 |
| CLE | 4th | 0:44 | | | NYJ 0 | Phil Dawson XP | 20-20 | 1 |
|
OT |
| NYJ | OT | -4:-44 | | | NYJ 0 | Santonio Holmes 37 yard Passing TD from Mark Sanchez | 26-20 | 9.7 |