Take it from a die hard informed ravens fan. Start Mendenhall or you will regret it. The steelers are going to run run and run some more. Probably 30 times in this game. Look for mendy to carry 15 times, Dweyer 10 and Redman 5. This is a no brainier.
A "no brainier"? LOL. I know it's "Da Raydas", but Reece is in line for at least 20 touches and he's going against a Saints defense that has been bad virtually all season, especially on the road. Mendenhall will eventually be the better option, as soon as Week 12 in fact, but he's a riskier play this week. Dwyer is a good bet to get roughly equal PT, and with Big Ben sidelined the Ravens will put added emphasis on stopping the run (e.g. 8 in the box) and forcing Leftwich to have to beat them.
i like stephens-howling. forget stark, and mendenhall's a tough call between his health questions and the indecisiveness in the backfield. at least the hyphen is the only choice and is playing a defense you can run on.
Ravens defense absolutely sucks this season. They've sucked all year and have been even worse since losing Webb and Lewis. If you're gonna start Mendy I wouldn't be worried about the defense....It'd be worried about him re-injuring himself or being on a snap count to ease him back into the offense.
That's what all of the "experts" are saying too. These are the same experts who told Mendenhall owners to sit him against Philadelphia and the same experts who told CJ2K owners to sit CJ2K against Houston, Chicago and Miami.
ravens d is terrible, and the last time mendenhall started in his first game back, he ran for over 5 yds per carry, and scored on a reception. your argument is invalid.
Very helpful, BlueCrimson. Folks, remember that when Mendenhall made his long-awaited return earlier this season against the Eagles, he immediately had a substantial role and a had a solid game that included a TD.
I remember that. But I also remember his next game against Tennessee. Redman got the start last week and look what happened. I like Mendenhall but not sure if I want to start him or not. If he were 100% healthy it would be a no brainer.
I would probably shy away from Mendenhall for one more week unless desperate. When Mendenhall made that Week 5 start, Dwyer and Redmen were basically doing nothing. Dwyer looks better now than he did then. Redman is basically the odd man out but i would see who gets the hot hand and the amount of touches each guy gets after the game.
Comments
KyleRuppFri 11/16/12 9:50 AM
mendenhall turner or hayweard bay? flex
Templeb3Fri 11/16/12 2:04 AM
mendenhall or marcel reece?
HernekerFri 11/16/12 1:40 AM
Take it from a die hard informed ravens fan. Start Mendenhall or you will regret it. The steelers are going to run run and run some more. Probably 30 times in this game. Look for mendy to carry 15 times, Dweyer 10 and Redman 5. This is a no brainier.
CommishBobCFri 11/16/12 12:46 PM
A "no brainier"? LOL. I know it's "Da Raydas", but Reece is in line for at least 20 touches and he's going against a Saints defense that has been bad virtually all season, especially on the road. Mendenhall will eventually be the better option, as soon as Week 12 in fact, but he's a riskier play this week. Dwyer is a good bet to get roughly equal PT, and with Big Ben sidelined the Ravens will put added emphasis on stopping the run (e.g. 8 in the box) and forcing Leftwich to have to beat them.
TimbowFri 11/16/12 12:56 AM
For a flex option would you pick Mendenhall or Aaron Hernandez?
TheOutlawsThu 11/15/12 4:39 PM
Who would you start at RB2?
Rashard Mendenhall vs Baltimore
James Stark vs Detroit
LaRod Stephens-Howling @ Atlanta
rmaxtpmxThu 11/15/12 7:42 PM
i like stephens-howling. forget stark, and mendenhall's a tough call between his health questions and the indecisiveness in the backfield. at least the hyphen is the only choice and is playing a defense you can run on.
TheOutlawsThu 11/15/12 9:33 PM
Thanks rmax!
Thias_777Thu 11/15/12 4:17 PM
I can start two. Standard scoring league.
Jamaal Charles vs Bengals
Steven Jackson vs NY Jets
Mendenhall vs Baltimore
Which two?
adic33Fri 11/16/12 1:26 AM
Charles and Jackson
BoysUnderJimmieThu 11/15/12 3:03 PM
1st start since njury and its agains raven D - better hope you have better options
Thias_777Thu 11/15/12 4:07 PM
Ravens defense absolutely sucks this season. They've sucked all year and have been even worse since losing Webb and Lewis. If you're gonna start Mendy I wouldn't be worried about the defense....It'd be worried about him re-injuring himself or being on a snap count to ease him back into the offense.
krc9683Thu 11/15/12 4:28 PM
ravens have sucked against the run should be a good game for mendenhall assuming he's 100% healthy
TheOutlawsThu 11/15/12 4:42 PM
That's what all of the "experts" are saying too. These are the same experts who told Mendenhall owners to sit him against Philadelphia and the same experts who told CJ2K owners to sit CJ2K against Houston, Chicago and Miami.
rmaxtpmxThu 11/15/12 7:49 PM
ravens d is terrible, and the last time mendenhall started in his first game back, he ran for over 5 yds per carry, and scored on a reception. your argument is invalid.
swagsterThu 11/15/12 2:19 PM
How many carries...
BlueCrimson27Thu 11/15/12 2:29 PM
between zero and all.
CommishBobCThu 11/15/12 3:20 PM
Very helpful, BlueCrimson. Folks, remember that when Mendenhall made his long-awaited return earlier this season against the Eagles, he immediately had a substantial role and a had a solid game that included a TD.
TheOutlawsThu 11/15/12 4:41 PM
I remember that. But I also remember his next game against Tennessee. Redman got the start last week and look what happened. I like Mendenhall but not sure if I want to start him or not. If he were 100% healthy it would be a no brainer.
lefties1Thu 11/15/12 8:31 PM
that was philly though. The Ravens D is down a bit but they're still no cakewalk
BlueCrimson27Fri 11/16/12 12:49 AM
I would probably shy away from Mendenhall for one more week unless desperate. When Mendenhall made that Week 5 start, Dwyer and Redmen were basically doing nothing. Dwyer looks better now than he did then. Redman is basically the odd man out but i would see who gets the hot hand and the amount of touches each guy gets after the game.